This is a list of every single Minecraft song ranked from best to least best (They are all really good). This list is based on my personal opinion and is subject to change as new songs are released.
I love all artists that have contributed to the Minecraft soundtrack and bought the Alpha and Beta albums on vinyl when they were released (Sadly the other albums were never released on vinyl) and own a lot of Lena Raine vinyls as well but keep in mind that there is most definitely a huge nostalgia factor in this list, even when I love newer songs too, older songs have way more nostalgia attached to them.
This also contains a few songs that were never released / removed from the game, but are official parts of the soundtrack.
Also, there is no order within the tiers, so the songs are not ranked within the tiers. (And even the tiers are quite blurry, I just needed a way to organize the songs.)
Note: I split this into two parts because my opinion about Alpha and Beta is too tainted (and there are way too many songs).
Click here for Alpha - Beta
Click here for 1.13 and above
Legendary Tier
Comforting Memories (Caves & Cliffs) - Kumi Tanioka
How did they manage to make me feel nostalgic with this one.
Dragon Fish (1.13) - C418
Otherside (Caves & Cliffs) - Lena Raine
This just feels like it was always a part of Minecraft.
Precipice (Tricky Trials) - Aaron Cherof
It fits perfectly into the theme of the update. I can imagine myself tackling the chambers while listening to this.
Pigstep (Nether Update) - Lena Raine
This song was the perfect first non-C418 song to be added to the game. It doesn’t try to imitate C418 and defined a new era of Minecraft music.
Aerie (Caves & Cliffs) - Lena Raine
Five
I love Minecraft quasi-lore additions. I’m really glad that they were willing to add more “lore” to the game. There is so much mystery in this music disc.
Creator (Tricky Trials) - Lena Raine
SS Tier
An Ordinary Day (Caves & Cliffs) - Kumi Tanioka
Infinite Amethyst (Caves & Cliffs) - Lena Raine
A Familiar Room (Trails & Tales) - Aaron Cherof
Rubedo (Nether Update) - Lena Raine
Komorebi (Tricky Trials) - Kumi Tanioka
Left to Bloom (Caves & Cliffs) - Lena Raine
One More Day (Caves & Cliffs) - Lena Raine
Deeper (Tricky Trials) - Lena Raine
Eld Uknown (Tricky Trials) - Lena Raine
S Tier
Stand Tall (Caves & Cliffs) - Lena Raine
Shuniji (1.13) - C418
So Below (Nether Update) - Lena Raine
Floating Dream (Caves & Cliffs) - Kumi Tanioka
Firebugs (The Wild Update) - Lena Raine
Relic (Trails & Tales) - Aaron Cherof
Puzzlebox (Tricky Trials) - Aaron Cherof
Labyrinthine (Caves & Cliffs) - Lena Raine
Echo in the Wind (Trails & Tales) - Aaron Cherof
Bromeliad (Trails & Tales) - Aaron Cherof
Endless (Tricky Trials) - Lena Raine
A Tier
Creator (Music Box Version) (Tricky Trials) - Lena Raine
Crescent Dunes (Trails & Tales) - Aaron Cherof
Wending (Caves & Cliffs) - Lena Raine
Watcher (Tricky Trials) - Aaron Cherof
Ancestry (Caves & Cliffs) - Lena Raine
Featherfall (Tricky Trials) - Aaron Cherof
Axolotl (1.13) - C418
Pokopoko (Tricky Trials) - Kumi Tanioka
B Tier
Yakusoku (Tricky Trials) - Kumi Tanioka
Chrysopoeia (Nether Update) - Lena Raine
Bad
There is no bad Minecraft song. Fool.